After discovering — to my furniture’s detriment — that the Apple HomePod and the Sonos One speakers can potentially leave white marks on certain wood surfaces, I decided to see what other smart speakers are capable of causing similar damage.
Not wanting to subject my mahogany cabinet to any more abuse, I bought a pine board from Home Depot, along with some mahogany stain and Howard’s Feed-N-Wax — an oil-based finish that was also used on my furniture.
As it turns out, the Google Home Max can damage wood just like the Apple HomePod and Sonos One, but there is some good news.
After letting the board dry, I placed the following nine smart speakers on it:
Amazon Echo (2nd gen)
Amazon Echo Plus
Amazon Echo Dot
Amazon Echo Show
Amazon Echo Spot
Google Home Max
Google Home Mini
Then, I left them on the board, turned off, for a little more than 27 hours. Here’s what happened.
Amazon Echo: No marks
Amazon Echo Plus: No marks
Amazon Echo Dot: No marks
Amazon Echo Show: No marks
Amazon Echo Spot: No marks
Apple HomePod: The HomePod left a telltale ring on the pine board, although it wasn't as prominent as the one on my cabinet.
Google Home Max: Large white mark, caused by the silicone pad that Google ships with the speaker.
Google Home Mini: No marks
Sonos One: Also left four small, white marks that were not as pronounced as the ones left by the others tested (nor as prominent as the one on my cabinet), but they were still visible.
Why hadn’t I noticed the Home Max’s white mark before, when Google’s speaker was sitting on my cabinet? Simple: I wasn’t using it with the silicone pad at the time.
Google ships the pad with the Max, but I had left the pad in the box, figuring it wasn’t that necessary. However, when devising this test, I decided to use the pad to see its effect. So, if you have or plan to purchase the Google Home Max, and want to place it on wood furniture, I would advise against using the silicone pad.
Update (2/21): A Google spokesperson thanked us for bringing this to their attention, and added "To date, we've not received any reports about this issue in regards to Max."
I still think the Sonos One, HomePod and Google Home Max (to a slightly lesser extent) deliver the best sound of all the smart speakers. When we put all three to the test, the Sonos One came out on top, but the Google Home Max was competitive, not only for its sound, but also for what you can do with Google Assistant. But if you purchase or own any of the speakers that can damage furniture, I advise placing it on a non-silicone pad or coaster.
- Smarter Home Guide: What You Need to Know (and Buy)
- 17 Alexa Skills For Your Smart-Home Devices
- The Best Cheap Smart Home Devices Under $100
Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips.
Thank you for signing up to Tom's Guide. You will receive a verification email shortly.
There was a problem. Please refresh the page and try again.